6.7 out of 10: okay
good: music choice, animation, interactive menu, alt. ending, no sprites!!!
bad: needs more signature moves
ugly: expected more, obviously a mario fan, and unesscary, horrible story
comment: it was good and I'm glad that you moved away from sprites. I wish more would do the same. Though it was obvious that you were a mario fan and didn't put much effort into sonic. I didn't care that mario had won, but sonic would of put up a better fight then that...anyway...it seemed to lack originallity, not that this fight hasn't been done before, but how many cartoons are there that have two video game characters pited against each other? That is why I gave a lower score in the style department...otherwise...it was good step for you to make it a REAL animation and not sprites, so I give kudos for that bumping the score to a 7...
OVERALL:
3 out of 5 R: Not bad!...in fact I liked it!
- mj